How we review

What the verdicts and scores mean.

Every review ends with a verdict and a score. Here’s what each one means, and what we do before we give them.

The verdict

Every review gets one of these three. It sits at the top, so you can stop reading there if that’s all you need.

Buy it

Worth full price now.

Wishlist it

Good, but wait for a sale, a patch or more content.

Skip it

Not worth your time right now, even on sale.

The score

Scores are whole numbers from 1 to 10, and we use the whole range. A 7 is a good game, not a disappointment.

  1. 10ExceptionalOne of the best in its genre.
  2. 8–9GreatEasy to recommend.
  3. 7GoodClear flaws, still worth playing.
  4. 5–6MediocreOnly for fans of the genre.
  5. 3–4PoorMore misses than hits.
  6. 1–2BrokenDoesn’t work, or barely does.

How we play

  • We finish the main path before reviewing. For games without one, we play at least 15 hours.
  • Occasionally a review of a big new release goes up while we’re still playing. When that happens, the review says so at the end and lists “Finished: No”, and we update it, including the score if it changes, once we reach the credits.
  • Every review lists the platform and hardware, whether we finished, and the game version.
  • If a major patch changes a game, we add an update note or re-review it.

What every review covers

  • Who the game is for, and who should skip it
  • How it’s designed: what works, what doesn’t, and why
  • Whether we got a review copy or bought it

Quick takes

Quick takes are short impressions of games our reviewer has put real hours into, posted between reviews. They use the same three verdicts, but they aren't full reviews: no score, no deep dive, and they don't follow the rules above about finishing a game first. Each one says how we got the game. Read the quick takes.

More on review copies, embargoes and how we use AI: ethics and disclosure.